User

Join the Qatar Living Community


Who's online

There are currently 93 users and 1430 guests online.




Big Brother is definitely here

britexpat's picture

FBI ready to demand detailed logs of Britons' internet and travel habits
• The Observer

The EU is close to finalising an agreement with the US that would allow the FBI to see the internet browsing habits and credit card histories of UK citizens.

However, the prospect of an agreement between Brussels and Washington that will lower barriers to swapping previously private data, including travel history and spending patterns, will alarm civil rights advocates.

Talks about the transfer of highly personal information held by the UK government and leading companies to American security agencies began following the September 2001 terrorist attacks. US counter-terrorism officials argued that increased information on the movements and habits of European residents would help prevent a repeat attack.

Details of a joint report by US and EU negotiators indicate that progress on the agreement is advanced, following years of opposition from European states with stricter privacy laws. One final hurdle still to be cleared is whether British and European citizens can sue the US government over its handling of their personal data.

Another area of concern relates to what 'appropiate safeguards' have been agreed to prevent the US authorities from requesting further information such as the religion, political opinion and 'sexual life' of a British resident.

PhillyEagles2007's picture

PhillyEagles2007 said Wow. I'm suprised England is ...

Wow. I'm suprised England is going to allow that.

 

britexpat's picture

britexpat said PhillyEagles2007 ...

Its not England, Its the EU..

As I said before, the Big Dog carries a lot of clout..

They are basically saying to the airlines and EU - "You want to come to the USA, then you have to agree to these"

 

PhillyEagles2007's picture

PhillyEagles2007 said "The EU is close to ...

"The EU is close to finalising an agreement with the US that would allow the FBI to see the internet browsing habits and credit card histories of UK citizens."

I know it the EU but I am suprised that England is letting the EU do this. Since they are an EU member I would think they should have a say rather than letting the EU dictate this policy to them. Also why is it only the UK and no one else?

 

MR PAUL's picture

MR PAUL said Well Britexpat, ...

"They are basically saying to the airlines and EU - "You want to come to the USA, then you have to agree to these"

Well simple, just dont go to the US !

Philly, its cos those limp wristed twats who claim to run our country have given most of our laws, choices and freedoms to the other twats in brussels !! Now, we have NO say in how our country is run....

..

NIL ILLEGITIMI CARBORUNDUM

 

AbuAmerican's picture

AbuAmerican said http://www.guardian.... This ...

http://www.guardian....

This is the full article, all about other aspects of big bro in your daily life.. All of this is kinda spooky indeed. All those who say I have noting to hide ect well you miss the point. This type of action says you are guilty until proven innocent and not the other way around..

This surveillance onslaught is draconian and creepy

The cameras, they are multiplying - and now they even have ears. But the state hasn't stopped to run the plan past us

Closed-circuit TV cameras are the crime-fighting tool so fiendishly sophisticated that they can be foiled by the wearing of a hood. Yet having stuck 4.2 million of the things around this country, with nary a consultation on the matter - nor any significant impact on crime statistics - efforts to pimp them to 2.0 status continue

This week it emerged that scientists at Portsmouth University are developing "listening" cameras. Artificial intelligence software will be able to recognise sounds such as breaking glass, so that, when such a noise is detected, they can rotate in its direction and capture the act of vandalism/terrorism/God that resulted in a milk bottle falling off your doorstep. I paraphrase slightly, but given that the most recent Home Office report on the matter found that better street lighting is seven times more effective at cutting crime than CCTV, the truly suspicious behaviour is our deepening obsession with surveillance.

The past few years have thrown up dozens of instances which made one wince to be a citizen of this septic isle, but a personal low came with the discovery that 500,000 bins had been fitted with electronic tracking devices. Transponders in bins ... Could any morning news item be more designed to force one back against the pillows, too embarrassed about one's country to start the day? Yes, as it turned out. A couple of months ago it was discovered that Poole borough council, in Dorset, had used the Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act - designed to track serious criminals and terrorists - to determine whether a school applicant and her parents lived where they said they did. They did, and were appalled to discover they had been spied on for three weeks, the subject of surveillance notes such as "female and three children enter target vehicle and drive off". Target vehicle, if you please! The thought of some deep-cover council drone jotting this stuff down as though it were an elite Delta Force operation is not as funny as it is horrifying.

Just who are these people, these swelling legions of unelected, ill-qualified monitors who wield such extraordinary power in our surveillance society? Clarification in one case came last year, when the civilian in charge of a Worcester police station's surveillance team was suspended after detectives found, among one day's footage, a 20-minute sequence of close-ups of a woman's cleavage and backside as she walked oblivious through the streets. Whether the woman ever discovered she was the star of a kind of pervert Truman Show is not recorded. But the offending monitor escaped with a warning and was - unbelievably - back in post within weeks.

In some city centres, such as Middlesbrough, speakers have been put on the cameras, so that those monitoring can interact with potential miscreants. Let's hope these remote bossy boots imagine they're involved in some high-level negotiation, in which they talk down a teenager from his decision to drop a hamburger wrapper on the pavement.

The former home secretary John Reid, on whose draconian watch the Middlesbrough scheme was approved, even suggested at its launch that schoolchildren should enter a competition to become the voice of the cameras - once again laying bare the government's desire to co-opt its citizens into the surveillance process at all levels. We are, of course, coming up to the time of year when we are ordered to shop our neighbours for acts of hosepipe, while the Shoreditch Trust recently trialled a scheme encouraging residents to watch live CCTV feeds on a special local channel, the better to assist in policing.

For all this creepy "outreach", though, the only hands-down beneficiaries of our CCTV obsession (apart from the revenue gatherers) have been broadcasters. For no good reason, all manner of TV networks have been furnished with hours of footage to pad out their witless police chase documentaries, or offensively cheap "street crime UK" shows. Britain's CCTV network: proudly supporting the Bravo channel.

The worst thing is the blithe insistence that this is all necessary and normal. We are watched more closely, by more cameras, with each passing day. But so faultlessly designed is our society that we have never come close to having a say on it.

There's a great bit in Woody Allen's movie Deconstructing Harry when Robin Williams's character goes out of focus, appearing as a sort of fuzzy version of himself, which sounds increasingly like the sort of sickness that should be courted by any attractive woman keen to walk through Worcester. That said, she could always don a hood. Yet there does seem a vaguely depressing irony in governments insisting that constant surveillance is essential to prevent our being overrun by repressive regimes who'd make us all cover our heads and the like. It's these initiatives that drive even the most pliant members of society to dream of taking just that precaution themselves, if only for a bit of privacy.

 

princess habibah's picture

princess habibah said yep the anti christ is on ...

yep the anti christ is on his ways! A manipulator, liar and thief he will pretend to be something he isn't only to reveal himself after he has gained trust, power and control of our lives.

Carry on dudes!

Maryum : Umm Hasan bint Abdullah Alshabrawishi

 

britexpat's picture

britexpat said AbuAmerican ...

I agree its very scary and in my opinion an infringement on civil liberties..

However, in relation to my article, I would agree with MP..

best way is to boycott the USA all together... Trouble is its easier said than done...

 

princess habibah's picture

princess habibah said The problem is that not ...

The problem is that not enough people will bother to stand up for themselves. Its something they put in our water I guess. ;)

Maryum : Umm Hasan bint Abdullah Alshabrawishi

 

AbuAmerican's picture

AbuAmerican said Aye Brit, haven't been to ...

Aye Brit, haven't been to the US in over 24 years, my boycott has been in place for quite some time!

 

britexpat's picture

britexpat said PH.. ...

It starts with a few..

i recall we used to go and march outside the South African embassy, during my university days..

The problem is that these days people have forgotten how to speak up or stand up for their rights..


 

princess habibah's picture

princess habibah said So lets do some protests ...

So lets do some protests Brit.. you can put your underwear on your head and I'll cover my face.... that should raise some eyebrows.

No your really right! We need to stand up for ourselves even if we stand alone. One person can make a difference!

Maryum : Umm Hasan bint Abdullah Alshabrawishi

 

Alexa's picture

Alexa said What is the reason for ...

What is the reason for "them" doing this?

A sense of humour is just common sense dancing, sadly, common sense has left the building and is dancing somewhere else.
Alexa

 

MR PAUL's picture

MR PAUL said Cos the Yanks are paranoid about everybody else !! ...

They are the worlds police after all ............

..

NIL ILLEGITIMI CARBORUNDUM

 

MR PAUL's picture

MR PAUL said read this link.... ...

http://www.jhunewsle...

..

NIL ILLEGITIMI CARBORUNDUM

 

Alexa's picture

Alexa said Paul, is it really ...

Paul, is it really "everybody" else?

A sense of humour is just common sense dancing, sadly, common sense has left the building and is dancing somewhere else.
Alexa

 

britexpat's picture

britexpat said Alexa.. ...

I personaly think that the Americans have become paranoid after 9/11, but also they are using 'terrorism or threat of terrorism" to enforce their own ideas.

Remember, since 9/11, the Americans have pumped billions into security services and these organziations have to justify their existence,.

 

princess habibah's picture

princess habibah said good point alexa! is it ...

good point alexa! is it everybody else?

Maryum : Umm Hasan bint Abdullah Alshabrawishi

 

MR PAUL's picture

MR PAUL said Yeah, i guess that would just about cover it..... ...

But i'm sure our Yank friends will confirm.

..

NIL ILLEGITIMI CARBORUNDUM

 

Alexa's picture

Alexa said quite frankly, i am a little ...

quite frankly, i am a little paranoid too...after 9/11, Riyadh, Al Khobar, Jeddah, London, Madrid......

A sense of humour is just common sense dancing, sadly, common sense has left the building and is dancing somewhere else.
Alexa

 

princess habibah's picture

princess habibah said Its just hard to trust ...

Its just hard to trust people in this world. I agree with that! Lets get real though even with all the mistrust we have does it make it okay/ neccessary to run surveillance to this extent?

Maryum : Umm Hasan bint Abdullah Alshabrawishi

 

princess habibah's picture

princess habibah said Besides being a paranoid ...

Besides being a paranoid person aren't you just a bit curious as to whether these were all set up by the us in the first place?

Maryum : Umm Hasan bint Abdullah Alshabrawishi

 

Alexa's picture

Alexa said I am not a paranoid person ...

I am not a paranoid person in general. It is just certain things that scare me.
What I am curious about is, how many plots were actually compromised due to "certain" measurments taken.
Besides, I do not like to be spied upon either, it does bother me immensely that my freedom of privacy and to some extent, movement, is taken away from me by people who are fanatic, brutal and have no thought about anything other than their own twisted ideals.

A sense of humour is just common sense dancing, sadly, common sense has left the building and is dancing somewhere else.
Alexa

 

britexpat's picture

britexpat said Alexa.. ...

As the saying goes.. "to be forewarned is to be forearmed...

We should be a little paranoid, but our governments and their agencies are going to far and we are losing our civil liberties..

As an example; The UK, passed a law allowing councils to "tap" people's phones if they were suspected of illegal acts.. This was mainly in response to terrorist threats..

It seems , many councils have been using phone tappeing to spy on householders to get information relating to house extensions, council tax, benefit claims etc..

this is to me an abuse of the system..

 

Alexa's picture

Alexa said Brit, as I said, I do find ...

Brit, as I said, I do find this as wrong as the next person.And yes, once you start....you never know where it will actually lead. Those things often take a life of their own. BUT....what to do, what not to do?
There is so much more going on that we ,the "dumb" public do not have any knowledge of....I had a little glimpse of it when living in Riyadh,when somebody close to me had connections to certain people who were gathering information about another "certain kind" of people....staggering, truly staggering!
So, I personally rather lose some of my privacy than finding myself and my family brutally murdered by certain people.

A sense of humour is just common sense dancing, sadly, common sense has left the building and is dancing somewhere else.
Alexa

 

catsniper's picture

catsniper said Part of world ...

Part of world policing...

Every lady hopes that her daughter will marry a better man than she did. And is convinced that her son will never find a wife as good as his father did!!!


 

MR PAUL's picture

MR PAUL said Team America, world police....... ...

It would be funny if it wasnt so serious an issue !

..

NIL ILLEGITIMI CARBORUNDUM

 

princess habibah's picture

princess habibah said How do you know those ...

How do you know those fanatic, brutal and have no sense for others does not also describe the USA goverment?

At the end of the day, they are out for themselves. this is in all the political uni textbooks if one dares to read. The very core of American politics is state domination of other territories.

how do we know that these attacks were not created by the USA in order to dominate the world through all these terrorism so called protection schemes?

The threat to yourself and person is far less by a few fanatical muslims then the US. In fact, the more control the US has the more freedom fighters we are going to see. Some who get the mark wrong and see bombing as a good thing. And the more control america has the more capability they will have to create false evidence (like the war in Iraq) to persecute those individual freedom fighters (harmless muslim and non muslim) who do not agree with world domination by the state.

Their is no democracy in this type of political system and alot of people will no longer have the right to protest for their rights and expect to be heard. And although I personally believe democracy is a red herring, even the idea will become non existant if we allow the goverment to monopolize our lives and control every move we make.

Maryum : Umm Hasan bint Abdullah Alshabrawishi

 

Alexa's picture

Alexa said Ah.....what a twisted tale ...

Ah.....what a twisted tale it is!

A sense of humour is just common sense dancing, sadly, common sense has left the building and is dancing somewhere else.
Alexa

 

britexpat's picture

britexpat said MP.. ...

Its the old question about "who watches the watcher".

Terrorism has to be addressed and on a global scale. however, the gathering and use of information/data has to be controlled to safe guard civil rights and liberties..

The following is real can be taken as funny, but shows the dangers...

Swedish authorities arrested a man for libel for falsely sending the FBI an email, ratting out his son-in-law by saying he had Al Qaeda ties.

The 40 year-old son-in-law was in the midst of divorcing the man's daughter, and his wife wanted him stay home and help with their child instead of traveling to the U.S., Agence France-Presse reports.

When the husband refused to stay home, his father-in-law wrote an email to the FBI saying the son-in-law had links to al-Qaeda in Sweden and that he was travelling to the US to meet his contacts.

He provided information on the flight number and date of arrival in the US.

The son-in-law was arrested upon landing in Florida. He was placed in handcuffs, interrogated and placed in a cell for 11 hours before being put on a flight back to Europe...


 

princess habibah's picture

princess habibah said It just goes to show that we ...

It just goes to show that we really can't believe anything we hear these days. At the end of the day, the media feeds us lies what the goverments would like us to believe.

If its not the muslim propaganda that america and the west is the enemy its the US propaganda that sophisticated terrorists networks actually exist. I try to take it all with a pinch of salt!

Maryum : Umm Hasan bint Abdullah Alshabrawishi

 

Alexa's picture

Alexa said Right...and 9/11 and all ...

Right...and 9/11 and all that was just fantasy, a bad dream, best to be forgotten.

A sense of humour is just common sense dancing, sadly, common sense has left the building and is dancing somewhere else.
Alexa

 

aaahmed81's picture

aaahmed81 said Next they'll want to know ...

Next they'll want to know how many times each person goes to the toilet each day, how long he/she stays there each time, and the amount of sh*t and volume of urine they produce....

 

mafiriyals's picture

mafiriyals said Alexa - Freedom Fighters are ...

Alexa - Freedom Fighters are here also ;(

 

Alexa's picture

Alexa said Sure...they have to think ...

Sure...they have to think what kind of waste facilities are needed in places like Abu Ghraib....all has to be taken into consideration....quite thourough, those folks....;)

A sense of humour is just common sense dancing, sadly, common sense has left the building and is dancing somewhere else.
Alexa

 

jasminejasmine's picture

jasminejasmine said regarding AbuAmerican's post about Poole ...

My sister lives in Poole, Dorset, (it's our home too). Recently a letter was sent by the council threatening her with prison if she failed to immediately bring in her wheelie bin after the refuse collectors (bin men) had been. They come at 11am on a Tuesday, she is being penalised for being one of the few people in the area who actually works. She has to come home at lunchtime now in case they come and take photos. I also believe that their new found confidence to bully innocent people about refuse (rubbish) comes from a new found power. I would happily submit my privacy to a government capable of running the country. Let me know if we get one...

 

Alexa's picture

Alexa said Plenty, mafi, plenty! A ...

Plenty, mafi, plenty!

A sense of humour is just common sense dancing, sadly, common sense has left the building and is dancing somewhere else.
Alexa

 

Winn's picture

Winn said Well, ther's something ...

Well, ther's something called too much information. Like You build up a huge haystack n then u look for a pin....

Terror groups world wide are getting much smarter in communications and finance. They depend on simplistic solutions like a messenger on a bike rather than satellites or phones. Was reading something abt coded messages thru internet sites teh other day...

Travel histories n such will not show whether it was the same person hu travelled in diff names...

But corporates might hav beter use for the info, i feel.

Somebody told me, "You are what you eat".Now I know why I'm nuts!!

 

mafiriyals's picture

mafiriyals said Alexa - it is like a pluge ...

Alexa - it is like a pluge :(

 

mafiriyals's picture

mafiriyals said winn - any freedom fighters ...

winn - any freedom fighters in Goa :( I will but them that drink for more freedom ;)

 

Winn's picture

Winn said Mafi:Goa- lotsa freedom n ...

Mafi:Goa- lotsa freedom n some fighters too...n knowing you u r likely to get urself beaten up sooner or later :-p

Somebody told me, "You are what you eat".Now I know why I'm nuts!!

 

britexpat's picture

britexpat said Winn.. ...

the idea is to gather as much data as possible, so matter how disparate and then use "intelligent analytical systems" to produce patterns or predict actions.

This is feasible. However, as with anything, it is not 100% accurate.


 

mafiriyals's picture

mafiriyals said Winn - I will get squadron ...

Winn - I will get squadron of Female Freedom Fighters to accompany me to check my enemy hideouts (Discos, Night clubs)and reward them lavishly ;)

 

britexpat's picture

britexpat said jasminejasmine ...

this was my whole point... Jobsworths get power and it goes to their heads.

 

Winn's picture

Winn said I Agree Brit, but there will ...

I Agree Brit, but there will be too many patterns that evolve to make sense of -even if you allow for all the multi-million-computations-a-second super computers.

Most counter terrorism success stories,IMHO,stem from the oldfashioned officer-on-the-beat or the men on the street using their brains!!

What I dont understand is why such an extensive search when most of the activities are from groups known suspected and even surveilled?

Somebody told me, "You are what you eat".Now I know why I'm nuts!!

 

britexpat's picture

britexpat said Winn.. ...

Life is not as simple as it used to be... Now communications are easier, travel is easier and the internet has brought people together.

"Data Mining" is now a maturing science.

Ofcourse another reason is that security is big business and billions of dolars are at stake.

 

princess habibah's picture

princess habibah said Alexa how do we really know ...

Alexa

how do we really know that 9/11 wasn't done by a few individuals who just got lucky. And their is absolutely no way some of these guys were part of some sophisticated set up. It is most likely that they were just off the beaten track and decided to get together after watching too many movies. And everything else could very well be propoganda.

And I think that the fact that small time cops have been the ones to thwart terrorists is enough evidence to say they probably do not belong to some big cell network.

If there was then I am more then confident that I would have heard about it and be invited in such networks!

Facts are that we don't know if what the goverment is telling us true or just exaggerated to suit their ambitions. Either way.. I don't believe a word that comes out of anyones mouth concerning the situation!

Maryum : Umm Hasan bint Abdullah Alshabrawishi

 

Alexa's picture

Alexa said PH, because, with 9/11 eg. ...

PH, because, with 9/11 eg. it turned out, that those people were educated in the tasks ahead quite some time before they happened.
Are you saying Al Qaeda does not exist? That they are stumbeling fools? Not to be taken serious? Why don't you tell that to the people who were so badly affected by their actions? I am sure you can find some people in London who have lost family and friends due to the actions of those people.
And IF the government is lying....the dead, IMHO speak for themselves.
The people who are not agreeing with the governments actions should than see to it themselves that those inflicting those horrors on others are brought to justice...maybe a good idea...would save the taxpayer a lot of money...but that is not going to happen...is it?

A sense of humour is just common sense dancing, sadly, common sense has left the building and is dancing somewhere else.
Alexa

 

Winn's picture

Winn said PH: Some clues as to the ...

PH: Some clues as to the organisation & Planning
1. 19 hijackers trained in handling flights- bunch of individuals getting lucky???dont think so!
2. Infiltration in to the country and formation of sleeper cells - along with all social security , licenses and sdocumentations of the individuals involved- no planning???
3.Big cell networks are constituted of a lot of individuals - some of whose fanatisicm overpowered their discretion and allowed themselves to be caught. Doesnt mean there was no cell.
4. Suicide squads: It takes extensive indoctrination to turn a human being into a live bomb. No way it can be achieved by chance or a coupla individuals.

Somebody told me, "You are what you eat".Now I know why I'm nuts!!

 

princess habibah's picture

princess habibah said Alexa it has been well ...

Alexa it has been well recognized that Al Qaeda does not exist. Even the US goverment has made a statement that this name was created initially by the US!

Yes Osama exists.. yes he influenced a few fools.. Yes they trained in some tactics.. through connections but they were not as organized as you think. I didn't want to say.. although I typed it many times but I happen to know nawaf al ghamdi who was in one of the attacks. He was not religious.. in fact he failed his studies from partying too much and knowing his personality probably thought it would be a fun ride. He was known to do stupid things like that and make rash decisions. I talked to his father one time and he was pretty upset with Nawaf about failing his studies and having girlfriends.

So yes I am trying to say that America has completely exaggerated the whole situation. And Al Qaeda does not exist.

Hence one of the reasons I do not believe a word that comes out of the medias mouth. Having experienced them writing articles about me and my family for decades and also knowing quite a few people who have been connected with Al Qaeda and sent to guat. bay.

One guy in particular had an anti western website in which he advocated rebellion against the west. In fact, I know of this guy so well that I would stake my life on the fact that he never even heard of Al Qaeda and never ever took part in the planning or actions of any terrorist act.

I have known guys who have been afghanistan to fight against russia. And not one of them have heard of Al Qaeda..

It just doesn't bloody exist! And Osama is not the ring leader of some sophisticated organization as he can barely look after himself at the moment. If he is still really alive.

So hell no I don't believe a word that comes out of the media concerning terrorism.

Maryum : Umm Hasan bint Abdullah Alshabrawishi

 

Alexa's picture

Alexa said Ok Habibah.....Al Qaeda does ...

Ok Habibah.....Al Qaeda does not exist, and the moon is made of cheese. Relax, it is all good!

A sense of humour is just common sense dancing, sadly, common sense has left the building and is dancing somewhere else.
Alexa

 

britexpat's picture

britexpat said PH.. ...

I agree that the "terrorism" threat is being played tio the full by governments to gain more control over individuals...However, the threat is real..

I was in a compound that was hit by terrorists in Saudi Arabia. Luckily, we managed to hide in the laundry room whilst the gunfight went on. My house was damaged, my son suffered minor injuries, my car destroyed and a dear 'muslim' friend was killed along with his wife and two children aged 3 years and 4 months. When i ventured out, I found my neighbour's three year old daughter in shock.

Please tell me that this was not the work of terrorists, especially in a Muslim country.

 

Winn's picture

Winn said PH- "it has been well ...

PH-
"it has been well recognized that Al Qaeda does not exist. Even the US goverment has made a statement that this name was created initially by the US"- can u quote any sources for this info?

Abt Nawaf al ghamdi- no one ever doubted the existence of hypocrats among this bunch.

Also how do u explain the Bin Laden video tapes that talk abt Al-qaeda that come out now n then? they too are fabricated by media?

Abt Osama being dead/alive..yeah u might b right...but cant say for sure, right?

Looks like u've known quite a lot of interesting characters!!( no offence intended) :-)

Somebody told me, "You are what you eat".Now I know why I'm nuts!!

 

Alexa's picture

Alexa said Habibah...people like you ...

Habibah...people like you are actually helping this cancer to spread...why? Simple...by denying it...sad though, where people like you could be on the front lines fighting it...you are the ones who know it...but no, you don;t..so the government, as uninformed as it may be, has to do the dirty work.

A sense of humour is just common sense dancing, sadly, common sense has left the building and is dancing somewhere else.
Alexa

 

princess habibah's picture

princess habibah said Brit expat I agree that the ...

Brit expat I agree that the threat is very real.. and let me say that I am so sorry to hear about your experience and your muslim neighbors.

Muslims are angry and their is alot of anti western propaganda. Something I have been equally active in trying to change. As most individuals have little knowledge about Islam.. particularly in non practicing saudi arabia.

Even then, the majority of muslims are completely against such activities. Yet that does not stop a few obsessed characters from committing criminal activities. At the end of the day these people are criminals and not neccessarily part of some large 10,000 member organization.

Committing a crime is wrong and punishable! However pockets of criminals exist all over the world. The difference is that we do not hear about it and it is not used to control the whole world through legistlation that Brit expat posted about phone tapping and surveillance.

Legislation which Brit Expat rightly said can be abused to hurt our democratic rights at the least. And even used to set individuals up and persecute the innocent! I do not put anything past the goverment!

Hell I can't even rent a house without the landlords trying to set me up so they don't have to give me my deposit. So how about the goverment who is in it for power, money and glory?

Maryum : Umm Hasan bint Abdullah Alshabrawishi

 

princess habibah's picture

princess habibah said Alexa people like me are ...

Alexa people like me are actually part of the solution! As terrorism is not part of Islam in any way!

I'm not one to pull wool over other peoples eyes or myself about Islam. I am very straight forward and have well researched my religion.

Whats more I am an american who was at one time young and naive to believe that America always had the worlds best interest in mind. However after my own personal experiences with some of the so called criminals who committed these acts I am no longer convinced.

If their was such a network then as I said.. alot of muslims such as myself would know about it.

And I cannot believe that any smart or intelligent person would believe the propaganda just because someone/or news station tells you it is the truth. If someone told you to jump off a bridge would you listen to them too?

The fact is that no one knows the entire truth! And no one can trust any goverment after they have already been caught in so many lies!

Maryum : Umm Hasan bint Abdullah Alshabrawishi

 

britexpat's picture

britexpat said PH.. ...

I am surprised that you label Saudi Arabia as "non practicing", since it is the cradle of Islam.

My compound wa attacked by men impersonting security personnel. They had security jeeps, grenades, heavv firearms and good logistics. The bomb detonated about 100 mtres from my house, but yet damaged my propety. They also videoed the attack.This cannot be done by a rabble. It needs supply lines and a good communicatios network.

I agree that they may be a minority. But its a large minority and the Muslim community as a wole has to stand up and denounce these actions, rather than burying their heads in the sand and coming up th conpiracy theories all the time.

 

Alexa's picture

Alexa said Habibah, I know that Islam, ...

Habibah, I know that Islam, the true Islam, has nothing at all to do with this.Never the less, people who commit these acts claim it does.
Habibah, a member of my family was in such an attack,also in Saudi. And my family and I lived in fear for quite some time , due to it. Now Saudi has taken rather vigorous steps to diminish those "deviants" as they are called there.But, it is easy for them, as they a. recognize the threat, and b. have a rather draconian regime which gives them the freedom to do as they please.
Besides, if even Saudi has rid themselves of Osama...how do you think other countries feel about him and his followers?

A sense of humour is just common sense dancing, sadly, common sense has left the building and is dancing somewhere else.
Alexa

 

princess habibah's picture

princess habibah said Brit expat I agree with you ...

Brit expat I agree with you in that we need to stop coming up with conspiracy theories. That is a huge problem in the muslim community.

I do not agree that they are burying their heads in the sand though. The majority of muslims actively detest all terrorist acts and have voiced this in numerous ways. From writing books, speaking on television (though this has been cut out by the media), and having anti terrorism conferences. In every mosque in the uk terrorism is usually talked against and in most islamic circles people talk against it.

The people of saudi arabia are not religious. Although the country is the land of Tawheed and religion is taught in the schools very few people bother to practice properly and are extremely cultural and corrupted.

It is no surprise that a pocket in saudi arabia could aquire such weapons as it is very easy through family connections to get a hold of such things. All one needs is to have a fanatical prince on his side. Or perhaps the guy who buys saudis weapons. My ex husband's uncle bought the weapons for saudi from America and UK and got a cut from each from each country. Through him alot of people could easily grab hold of such things without the goverment even knowing about it. Saudi has alot of corruption!

However, I would seriously doubt that this was some huge organization let alone connected with some made up Al Qaeda that doesn't even exist. It was most likely a group of muslims who wanted to show westerners a lesson!

This type of ideology is a threat. Their is no doubt that a large number of muslims carry these beliefs however I have never heard of nor seen any such organization as the one constantly talked about on TV. To be honest, most muslims are all talk and no action.

Maryum : Umm Hasan bint Abdullah Alshabrawishi


 

Rumpelstiltskin's picture

Rumpelstiltskin said the solution is very simple ...

if you want to feel safe & have your people feel safe, well then stop your terrorist acts against others...no? :-)
if you want to invade countries & kill people here & there then it is very fair that you & your people will get a share of the fire-works

For every action there is a reaction

Even a child knows this fact :-)

 

princess habibah's picture

princess habibah said Alexa your not the only one ...

Alexa

your not the only one scared! I am also scared! Everytime I see another muslim on a plane (particular a non bearded one) I freak out.

I just do not believe that the situation is accurately depicted or that America has the right to develop a big brother type goverment. That also scares the crap out of me!


 

britexpat's picture

britexpat said PH.. ...

A friend's teenage son suddenly disppeared to Pakistan five years ago.. They managd to trackhim down to the Afghan border and py a ransom to bring him back...

Thousands of Saudis, Pakitanis and Arabs went to fight initially against the Russians in Afghanistan. Some even went to Chehniya.. Many are now fighting in Iraq..

Why are so many doing this and why doesn't the peacefulmajority take steps to stop this??

 

Rumpelstiltskin's picture

Rumpelstiltskin said see how 1 incident has effected you ...

"Habibah, a member of my family was in such an attack"

then you can imagine how does it feel if this was the daily breakfast for some people/nations

 

princess habibah's picture

princess habibah said First things is first... the ...

First things is first... the war against russia in afghanistan was considered an islamically condoned jihaad. So was the war in chech. And most muslims agree with that.

The only reason the invasion of america against afghanistan was not legistlated by the scholars (although some muslims still warranted it as a jihad due to their own support of the taliban) is because the taliban were deobandites and on plain error according to many scholars. However, for alot of muslims this is still up in the air and many believe that America had no right to invade a country for one individual and kill thousands in the process.

The situation is somewhat different in Iraq as Saddam hussein and the baathist party are considered non muslims by many scholars. Really it should have been a muslim country to sort the two of them out but we are too weak islamically to do so ...

Most of your average day (uneducated about islam) muslims are happy that saddam is gone. Particularly the shias and kurds and it is only very few who supported the iraqi regime who felt it an obligation to call jihaad in Iraq.

For both the Iraq and Afghanistan invasions by america many of the muslims who did not support the regimes simply felt that America had no business in those countries and therefore felt they were doing jihaad by protecting their muslim brothers and sisters who are being killed.

The same mentality exists concerning the crisis in palestine and also terrorist cells who believe that America and its supporters are the biggest murderers of this century. And they feel it is their islamic duty to fight against a non muslim power with a superiority complex that wishes to dictate and influence the way they live.

Where as the palestinians feel it is their islamic duty to fight in any means possible for their land and dignity that Israel and through americas support has been wrongfully taken away.

Maryum : Umm Hasan bint Abdullah Alshabrawishi

 

britexpat's picture

britexpat said PH.. ...

So what you're baically saying is that in all these "conflicts" the Muslims were either led astray or did so out of ignorance..

You see what I mean by "burying your head in the sand" ?

 

princess habibah's picture

princess habibah said doesn't it make sense that ...

doesn't it make sense that some element of ignorance and being led astray had to happen from both sides for conflicts to have started.

A fight takes two to tango! And the cause was not the actual war. It would be naive to believe that every move America has made is for security measures. Given that their own political policy is to dominate other territories.
Both sides have alot of issues. And even more so both people have been subjected to leaders trying to justify their actions. And hide their faults.

All muslims had a legislated jihad in chechnya and Afghanistan because it was an invasion over land. Any persons right! Some (few) muslims felt protective of their muslims brothers in Afghanistan, Iraq and palestine from American and Israel invasions. Again it is also their right to protect their muslim brothers from such wrongful invasion. And in fact, the only reason the scholars said it was unlawful was 1.) unlawful to do so in protecting the corrupt regimes and 2.) because we did not have enough strength to fight against America or Israel and therefore needed to take a step back and gain more strength.

And personally I would have not hesitated had the scholars called for jihaad due to America and Israel unlawfully invading those countries.

However, jihaad does not include suicide bombings or killing innocent people. I.e. going to europe and blowing a few things up.

That is all due to our (wests) ignorance and being led astray due to our own (the wests) hunger for power and control which have had negative consequences in the Islamic world. We are a victim of the international problems our goverments have created due to our own superiority complexes. (I.E. we think we have the best system in the world and decree that all others should think so too)

Having said all that .. how serious is the terrorist threat truly? (not the media scare it is made to be) And how can we, in the west, show the muslims that we are all not bad and voice our opinions concerning the wrongs of our goverment. (not being racist and islamicphobic would be a start)

Earlier you mentioned that muslims don't have a voice.. I would like to know where is the voice of westerners who are against the terrorist and atrocities supported and enacted by western goverments. Why do you guys not speak up against such things. And try to support muslims and also sympathise with their situation?

At the end of the day, while I do not agree with the ideology of the majority muslims. And definately not the terrorist acts of the minorities. I also do not agree with the unprecedented support of and westerners who also have their head buried in the sand concerning their own goverments.

Maryum : Umm Hasan bint Abdullah Alshabrawishi

 

Alexa's picture

Alexa said OMG, Habibah...the american ...

OMG, Habibah...the american public constantly speaks out against the government...just watch some TV...not CNN ,Fox news etc....down to earth american programs..all the time they make fun of the government....South Park, Jay leno..just to mention two. The last election was a farce...everybody knows that...think Florida...How many people constantly want the troops to come home...I could go on and on...
the Brits....geez, they are just putting the cream on the cake...you will hardly find anybody in support of Tony and his antics.
So, where do they bury their heads in the sand?

BUT...and here comes the big one...they rather put up with their government, than having people come and kill them for twisted ideologies.
and twisted they are....the blame game has to stop....
This, of course, is from a solely western point of view. I do know, that the '
terrorists" blame the other "terrorists " for what is happening...so...what to do?

A sense of humour is just common sense dancing, sadly, common sense has left the building and is dancing somewhere else.
Alexa

 

britexpat's picture

britexpat said PH.. ...

With all due respect. I write to the western papers regularly. When there are protests against the war, it is usually the "westerners" who march and make their voices heard.. The majority of Muslims sit at home and complain of government policies and racism, but don't take to the streets or make their voices heard..

You keep talking about scholars . Why not think for yourself. Stand up for what you think is right. Let your voice be heard...Too many muslims are led astray by so called scholars..

 

Dracula's picture

Dracula said From Dante's Inferno: Canto ...

From Dante's Inferno: Canto XIII, the suicide's soul...

...
It falls into the forest, and no part
Is chosen for it; but where Fortune hurls it,
There like a grain of spelt it germinates.

It springs a sapling, and a forest tree;
The Harpies, feeding then upon its leaves,
Do pain create, and for the pain an outlet.
...
Behind them was a forest full of black
She-mastiffs, ravenous, and swift of foot
As greyhound, who are issue from the chain.

On him who had crouched down they set their teeth,
and him they lacerated piece by piece,
Thereafter boare away those aching members

Thereat my Escort took me by the hand,
And lead me to the bush, that all in vain
Was weeping from its bloody lacerations.
myspace layouts


 

a merry can muslim's picture

a merry can muslim said Alexa, Please watch this ...

Alexa, Please watch this youtube video regarding whether al-Qa'eeda exists or not.

http://www.youtube.c...

The foremost expert in this field is shown in this video. His name is Jason Burke and wrote a very telling book called 'Al-Qaeda: The True Story of Radical Islam'

Game recognizes game and you're looking kinda unfamiliar right now... -- Riley Freeman

 

Rumpelstiltskin's picture

Rumpelstiltskin said everybody speaks against their governments ...

"the american public constantly speaks out against the government..."
But the difference is; you guys ELECT criminal/terrorist governments who, in their turn, decide who to place as rulers/governments for us people. And when we speak against our governments (who are placed by YOUR governments), then YOUR governments order OUR governments to call these protesters as "terrorists" (although YOUR governments "believe in, and promote democracy")

 

britexpat's picture

britexpat said A Merry can muslim.. ...

The root causes of the dissatisfaction Muslims feel against Western powers are numerous. I am sure that some are justified.

However, the taking of lives and carrying out acts of terrorism is not only against the essence of islam, but also acts to widen the gap of misunderstanding.


 

britexpat's picture

britexpat said Rumpelstiltskin ...

i think you said it very well..

We "elect" and you allow yourselves to be enslaved/governed. why not stand up for yourselves and say ENOUGH.

You must also understand that whilst we would all like to live in La La land with milk and honey, reality is somewhat different.

ALL nations take steps to do what they percieve to be best for their own people. This is exactly what the USA and others are doing.

 

Rumpelstiltskin's picture

Rumpelstiltskin said "We "elect" and you allow yourselves..." ...

This means you guys ARE electing the evil governments that are having wars & invasions around the world, thus you are actually participating, as civillians, in these wars...so you have to take the consequences!

 

britexpat's picture

britexpat said Rumpelstiltskin ...

As an elected government, i am authorizing them to act on my behalf. Sometimes they get things wrong. In that case, i have the right to vote them out the next time.

I do not regard my government as evil. in fact, i believe that they are sometimes too liberal in some actions.


 

Alexa's picture

Alexa said Mcm, very ...

Mcm, very interesting...could only see part of it though...it constantly stops...:(
Regardless of IF or if NOT al Qaeda exists, attacks have happened in their name...it does to me, not matter under what name those people operate, fact is, they do.

A sense of humour is just common sense dancing, sadly, common sense has left the building and is dancing somewhere else.
Alexa

 

a merry can muslim's picture

a merry can muslim said Brit... are you expecting an ...

Brit... are you expecting an argument from me on that point???!!

I am merely pointing out that there is a position held by many 'normal' people that 'al-qa'eeda' is a bunch of BS that some Muslims latched onto because of their issues with the American government. It was not the creation of the fanatic and deviant bin Laden...

Game recognizes game and you're looking kinda unfamiliar right now... -- Riley Freeman

 

a merry can muslim's picture

a merry can muslim said Alexa I understand where you ...

Alexa I understand where you are coming from... BUT... I think it does matter...

If covert factions who operate within certain 'democracies' are utilizing this NAME in order to fuel the fire in a 'war' on terror... PLEASE... see how much that matters....

Game recognizes game and you're looking kinda unfamiliar right now... -- Riley Freeman

 

Alexa's picture

Alexa said If we would say, that OBL ...

If we would say, that OBL had any hand in it, IMHO it has NOTHING to do with the American gov. It is a personal vendetta between the house of Al Saud and OBL.

A sense of humour is just common sense dancing, sadly, common sense has left the building and is dancing somewhere else.
Alexa

 

a merry can muslim's picture

a merry can muslim said bin Laden... or as I prefer ...

bin Laden... or as I prefer to call him 'Emmanuel Goldstein'... is a tool.

He is the fanatic's head cheerleader... My brain will not let me believe that this man is responsible for anything other than being a cheerleader....

In fact, directly after the Sept 11 attacks he denied responsibilty BUT praised the acts... THEN when he realized this was his wet dream come true... He started saying how they had planned this for such and such a time...

Reichstag..... Marinus van der Lubbe.... Twin Towers/Pentagon.... Usamaah bin Laden.....

Game recognizes game and you're looking kinda unfamiliar right now... -- Riley Freeman

 

britexpat's picture

britexpat said A Merry can muslim.. ...

Covert agencies will always take "measures" to further their aims. we saw this with the Iran/Contra affair. Mossad and I am sure others do the same.

In this instance "Al Qaeda" is used as a bogeyman to give the fight on terror a focus. something the ordinary person in the street can relate to..

However, it is also naive to think that Al-Qaeda or a "network" does not or cannot exist. Goen are the days of Bader Meinhoff and red Brigade. Now, especially with the advancement of communications, "like minded" groups are able to work together to achieve their common goals.