Under-skilled expats blamed for low output

_noms_
By _noms_

Under-skilled expats blamed for low output rate in Qatar

A study has expressed concern over the declining productivity rates in Qatar, pointing out that the low man-hour output constitutes a major challenge to sustainable development in the country.
The study, which was issued by the Population Committee at the General Secretariat for Development Planning, said the average productivity per hour in Qatar had declined from 4.8% between 1990 and 2000 to 1.8% between 2000 and 2007, which the study blamed on the labour market policy.
“This is very low compared to what has been achieved by China (10.1%), Bahrain (5.13%), India (4.1%) and Oman (4.18%) in 2007,” the study said, citing findings of a report issued by the Conference Board, an international business and research organisation.
The study held the large numbers of the under-skilled expatriate workforce responsible for the low output per hour experienced by the country.
“What is alarming is that over half of the expatriate workforce (55.9%) are either uneducated or below secondary education level,” the study said.

http://gulf-times.com/site/topics/article.asp?cu_no=2&item_no=314792&ver...

COVID-19 Banner
By Eagley• 11 years 10 months ago.
Eagley

mkweng, some companies have it the other way around - Low salary, high production, high salary, sitting on a***!!

This survey also conducted in a bank :P

*****************************************

The Cookie Monster said it.

By mangkepweng• 11 years 10 months ago.
mangkepweng

low salary

less production

high salary

higher production

By anonymous• 11 years 10 months ago.
anonymous

Why I'm not surprised?

By Don Robert• 11 years 10 months ago.
Don Robert

I'm sorry Gica Contra, not interested.

"Do not do unto others what you don't want others to do unto you(Wag kang gay-an, kung mang gagay-an ka, wag gay-on)"

By anonymous• 11 years 10 months ago.
anonymous

Don, read my previous post....you copycat! :)

By nicaq25• 11 years 10 months ago.
nicaq25

Don Robert..LOL!

http://rakabayan.webs.com/

By Don Robert• 11 years 10 months ago.
Don Robert

skilled expats chatting in QL instead of working should be the one to be blamed for low output...Thank you

"Do not do unto others what you don't want others to do unto you(Wag kang gay-an, kung mang gagay-an ka, wag gay-on)"

By gtim• 11 years 10 months ago.
gtim

You've got the point Vperez... should not blamed it to expat workers. In the 1st place they should upgrade their hiring system... screen the applicants, hire the qualified and give the right compensation and benefits. But what i observed is the other way, they are hiring the unskilled and uneducated workers coz they want to pay them less and save money...

By nicaq25• 11 years 10 months ago.
nicaq25

do u think this study is fair enough with you? Because in my perspective although me & you do not belong to the unskilled labor force as what they mean here, the word 'expatriates' generally covers almost all foreign workers here and comprise the workforce of Qatar. Blaming expats not fair though.

http://rakabayan.webs.com/

By SHAJIV• 11 years 10 months ago.
SHAJIV

For sure, these two category people will not work as CEO or MD, (either uneducated or below secondary education level,”) they must be working as labors of different level. What it means then?

By nicaq25• 11 years 10 months ago.
nicaq25

nothing to do with being un-skilled.

Did they say; professional? or non-professional expats?

It said only: “What is alarming is that over half of the expatriate workforce (55.9%) are either uneducated or below secondary education level,” the study said.

Well, are you one of the above?

http://rakabayan.webs.com/

By alrama_s• 11 years 10 months ago.
alrama_s

1. expat + small salary = small work

2. local + big salary = small work

so what's the difference between expats and local. they must not blame it all to expats....

please review again the study you are telling to all of us......tnx...

"always be sincere even when you don't mean it"...

By anonymous• 11 years 10 months ago.
anonymous

totally agree with you. the Sheikhs are probably not even aware that this is happening.

_______________________________________________________

"You cannot propel yourself forward by patting yourself on the back."

By SHAJIV• 11 years 10 months ago.
SHAJIV

Is the productivity wholly depends on labors only??????? i don't think so!

By stealth• 11 years 10 months ago.
stealth

They didn't say anything about corruption right.

By anonymous• 11 years 10 months ago.
anonymous

Chuck in corruption as well and that also affects productivity... look at the roads for example...

By anonymous• 11 years 10 months ago.
anonymous

@ angel16...FYI,there are unqualified people of almost EVERY major nationality in this country doing jobs they've never done in their live in postions of authority & who've got those jobs by means other than the fact that they actually deserve it,don't know which expat group you're referring to here but irrespective of that,what you should be saying is remove ALL unskilled/unqualified people IRRESPECTIVE of nationality...

By angel16• 11 years 10 months ago.
angel16

they must reduce them,or remove those unskilled workers...

By anonymous• 11 years 10 months ago.
anonymous

Discrimination and corruption is the major cause of low productivity.......and everyone knows it.

Are you nuts?......no doubt I am crazy about you!

By JaCo• 11 years 10 months ago.
JaCo

that made me lol.

you get what you paid for (duh)! highly skilled professionals for less than qr1,000/month? yeah right.

By Gypsy• 11 years 10 months ago.
Gypsy

It is the expatriates, however it's the locals fault for hiring uneducated, inexperienced expatriates and paying them nothing and not demanding that they get proper training before they throw them out onto construction sites. You get what you pay for is all I say.

By sMaRt_iDiOt• 11 years 10 months ago.
sMaRt_iDiOt

under-skilled locals made this survey. Sorry.. not my intention to offend.

By azilana7037• 11 years 10 months ago.
azilana7037

contributes to the low productivity output rate...really???

And the 44.1% NON-EXPATS busts their butts working? whehehehe....thanks for making me laugh...

By flanostu• 11 years 10 months ago.
flanostu

survey must've been conducted in a bank.

By GodFather.• 11 years 10 months ago.
GodFather.

This will only change when the locals start to lead by example and do some work too?

-----------------

HE WHO DARES WINS

By Alumnar• 11 years 10 months ago.
Alumnar

... who sell Visas to people so they can work for whoever they want? For how many times more the price then it costs them?

This is the future and the way to be? For me it only has one name:

SLAVERY!!!

By stevethetyke• 11 years 10 months ago.
stevethetyke

Depends upon what they were producing (construction wise) between 1990 and 2000. I hear all the major developments here are fairly recent.

By Alumnar• 11 years 10 months ago.
Alumnar

Pay skilled workforce decent salaries. Invest in training programs. Don't overwork and underpay them. Use incentives and show them appreciation. Give them proper accomodation and allowances so they can eat enough to be able to work properly... and I could go on and on here.

It would be nice to see how Qatar would do with local people only doing all the jobs for a year. Can a country go bankrupt? If not the case, it can sure be CHAOS!

By blueRoSe• 11 years 10 months ago.
blueRoSe

there must be a big mistake...shouldn't it be the other way around???

God grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change, the courage to change the things I can & the wisdom to know d difference.

By britexpat• 11 years 10 months ago.
britexpat

I wonder how they calculate the "Manhour output" ??

I mean how does a mnhour output of a road surfacer compare to one of a manufacturing plant worker in China ?

By anonymous• 11 years 10 months ago.
anonymous

I was still half asleep but realized it needed some clarification.

Actually I think Qatar is fortunate that even in cases where people are paid peanuts and have horrible living conditions, most still do their jobs pretty well. I guess it is not as much "output" as you would get with slaves, though... :-/

 

 

 

I didn't drink the kool-aid! -- PM

By anonymous• 11 years 10 months ago.
anonymous

Exactly, PM. I work for 25.000 and Einstein would have asked for 250.000. That's why they have to have crap like me.

By anonymous• 11 years 10 months ago.
anonymous

nice clarification :)

_______________________________________________________

"You cannot propel yourself forward by patting yourself on the back."

By anonymous• 11 years 10 months ago.
anonymous

and deserve what you get. If you don't pay enough and provide good working and living conditions to attract and retain excellent employees then that is where the blame should be put.

 

 

 

I didn't drink the kool-aid! -- PM

By anonymous• 11 years 10 months ago.
anonymous

 

 

 

I didn't drink the kool-aid! -- PM

By nomad_08• 11 years 10 months ago.
nomad_08

allow them to enter malls and souqs on Fridays and their output will increase.

By the-birdie• 11 years 10 months ago.
the-birdie

the development history of Middle East countries shuld also be written with the sweat, tears & blood of expatriate labour. ( I used the word "also" ) .

let us think, how the home countries of these expatriates function.

whether it is India, Pakistan, Bangladesh....... to UK or US.. take any nation, the nationals in those countries were involved in the jobs "A" to "Z" grades.

let us imagine a scenario - where all the expatriates are driven back home. How these countries will survive ? Do these nationals really "work" ?

By anonymous• 11 years 10 months ago.
anonymous

i think it was

"you get paid for what you deserve"

if im not mistaken.

_______________________________________________________

"You cannot propel yourself forward by patting yourself on the back."

By heero_yuy2• 11 years 10 months ago.
heero_yuy2

You get what the non-Qatari sponsors pay for a deserve.

"Everything in this book may be wrong." Illusions: The Adventures of The Reluctant Messiah by Richard Bach

By anonymous• 11 years 10 months ago.
anonymous

That's not Qatar's problem. Jobs for their citizens comes first.

By britexpat• 11 years 10 months ago.
britexpat

The economies of the countries supplying the labour would be negatively affected..

By Nakamura• 11 years 10 months ago.
Nakamura

I agree with exiledsaint

By anonymous• 11 years 10 months ago.
anonymous

They should nationalise the labour jobs and then the productivity will go up.

By mintus• 11 years 10 months ago.
mintus

MAybe if the random 1 or two locals would spend more than a few hours a week in there workplace this may go up.

By vperez• 11 years 10 months ago.
vperez

what about those under-skilled and uneducated locals who are supposed to be the one making progress for their own country?

MyHotComments

By anonymous• 11 years 10 months ago.
anonymous

Gica, 'educated' expatriates can do both at the same time. It's the undereducated who can only either do QL or do their work!

By anonymous• 11 years 10 months ago.
anonymous

There are a lot of educated expatriates but they are loosing time on QL. MOD, just for test, close the site during normal working hours and than will check the productivity again! :)

By anonymous• 11 years 10 months ago.
anonymous

are they referring to the Sponsorship system here in Qatar??

please forgive my ignorance :O(

_______________________________________________________

"You cannot propel yourself forward by patting yourself on the back."

By anonymous• 11 years 10 months ago.
anonymous

The study says that salaries have to be doubled or tripled to attract educated expats, brit.

By britexpat• 11 years 10 months ago.
britexpat

I still don't see what the study is trying to say ?

By anonymous• 11 years 10 months ago.
anonymous

they are in-part to be blame as well..

_______________________________________________________

"You cannot propel yourself forward by patting yourself on the back."

By anonymous• 11 years 10 months ago.
anonymous

Why should expats be motivated and productive? It's not their country, they can't get citizenship. If Qatar wants to change this, they have to give all civil rights to the expats.

By nicaq25• 11 years 10 months ago.
nicaq25

what else is new?

http://rakabayan.webs.com/

By anonymous• 11 years 10 months ago.
anonymous

We know for fact that most of the construction labor workforce in Qatar are either uneducated or below secondary education level.

Qatar Living favorite classy jokes: "Remove by MOD" or "OOPS" Don't you get it? It is the last joke or posting in QL that you are going to read about.

Graduated from Xavier Institute for Higher learning

By _noms_• 11 years 10 months ago.
_noms_

Yet again expats are to be blamed !!!

~noms~

-----------------------------------------

"Before God we are all equally wise ' and equally foolish" - Albert Einstein

Log in or register to post comments

More from Qatar Living

GCO launches interactive COVID-19 measures guide for travelers coming to Qatar

GCO launches interactive COVID-19 measures guide for travelers coming to Qatar

Qatar’s Government Communications Office (GCO) has launched an interactive COVID-19 travel measures guide for people planning to travel to Qatar.
Witness Qatar’s journey in the Tokyo 2020 Olympic Games

Witness Qatar’s journey in the Tokyo 2020 Olympic Games

An event of high significance for Olympic game lovers, you will soon be able to witness 15 Qatari athletes representing Qatar who will be competing across seven sports categories.
Ashghal announces temporary closure of Corniche Street

Ashghal announces temporary closure of Corniche Street

The four-day closure will go into effect from 12 am on Friday, August 6 until 5 am on Tuesday, August 10, 2021.
Simple steps to lose weight healthily – Part 1

Simple steps to lose weight healthily – Part 1

Reaching your ideal and healthy weight only requires a few simple alterations in your lifestyle including increasing the quality of the food you usually consume.
WATCH: QL Fitness | Episode 1 | Intro to Bodyweight Training

WATCH: QL Fitness | Episode 1 | Intro to Bodyweight Training

Episode 1 of Qatar Living Fitness on bodyweight training
WATCH: Mohamed Al Rumaihi, Tala Abujbara named Team Qatar's flagbearers for Olympic Games opening ceremony

WATCH: Mohamed Al Rumaihi, Tala Abujbara named Team Qatar's flagbearers for Olympic Games opening ceremony

Qatar Olympic Committee (QOC) has announced that Mohamed Al Rumaihi and Tala Abujbara will be Team Qatar's flagbearers in the Olympic Games opening ceremony today.
WATCH:Quest, Qatar’s largest indoor theme park to open July 1

WATCH:Quest, Qatar’s largest indoor theme park to open July 1

Featuring over 30 rides and attractions, including the world-famous restaurant Planet Hollywood, Quest will soon open its doors on July 1, 2021.
WATCH:Fresh Local Dates Festival 2021 to feature over 80 farms

WATCH:Fresh Local Dates Festival 2021 to feature over 80 farms

Starting today from 4 pm at Souq Waqif, the Fresh Local Dates Festival will witness the participation of over 80 local farms and end on July 30, 2021.